Season one · Bucksport, Maine

Three deaths.
One disappearance.

Two families seeking answers.

A six-part investigative podcast following the search for Colin Arey and the questions surrounding three connected deaths.

In development · Release date to be announced

Original Doubly Dead artwork showing illustrated Bucksport landmarks, homes, a mill, and a car.
Podcast artwork by Harmony Witte

The disappearance of Colin Arey

A missing person.
A town full of questions.

In 2017, Colin Arey, a young gay man from Bucksport, Maine, disappeared. Nearly a year and a half passed before anyone reported him missing.

Journalist Jacqui Fulton’s search leads to the deaths of Colin’s mother, Christy Appleby, and two other people, Robin Davis and her father, Kirk. Suspicious fires and financial schemes deepen the questions their families have about what happened.

Working with fact-checker Fendall Fulton and private investigator Jen Dorman, Jacqui follows the evidence through a community where people are afraid to speak. Their reporting has already helped reopen one closed case.

Listen

Step into the investigation.

Hear the early extended trailer for Doubly Dead: The Disappearance of Colin Arey.

Doubly Dead · Early extended trailer

Listen on SoundCloud →

An early introduction to the project. The episode structure and reporting have developed since this recording.

The people behind the cases

Four lives at the heart of this story.

Colin Arey

Colin graduated early from high school and completed a fashion design program in New York City. He loved Harry Potter and played Pokémon Go along the Bucksport waterfront. Those closest to him remember his warmth, kindness, and creativity.

Christy Appleby

A mother of four, Christy loved camping with her family, scrapbooking, cooking, and her two dogs. She spent years working with elementary school children in special education and was continuing her own education when she died.

Robin Davis

Robin was a familiar, much-loved face in town, working first at a local grocery store and later as a manager at McDonald’s. Her son was the center of her world. She loved bringing family and friends together.

Kirk Davis

A longtime Bucksport Paper Mill worker and skilled carpenter, Kirk enjoyed working on cars. He was a loving father and grandfather who, later in life, rekindled his romance with his high school sweetheart.

Original illustration of the bridge at Bucksport.

The approach

A reporter’s notebook.
An investigation unfolding.

Audio diaries and field recordings bring listeners into the work as it happens: the leads that stall, the discoveries that change its direction, and the disagreements that need to be worked through.

Family interviews give the reporting its emotional stakes. Police files and other records help establish what the team can prove and what remains uncertain.

The title reflects what happens when people disappear from public attention and their cases lose urgency. This series follows two families determined to keep that from happening.

The team

Reporting, research, and investigation.

Reporter & audio documentarian

Jacqui Fulton

she/they

Jacqui is a former public radio reporter, a Salt Institute and Transom graduate, and a recipient of the American Bar Association’s Silver Gavel Award for their work with Civics 101. Their stepson’s disappearance led them to investigate gaps in the missing persons system—and eventually to Colin’s case.

Fact checker & research editor

Fendall Fulton

they/them

Fendall’s work includes projects for Frontline, Wondery, and CBS News. A former digital archivist and researcher at New Hampshire Public Radio, they piece together records and timelines, test assumptions, and help report, write, and edit the series.

Private investigator

Jen Dorman

she/her

Jen is a former police officer, an EMT, and the owner of Northland Investigation & Consulting. She has spent years investigating these cases pro bono, reviewing police files, interviewing witnesses, and searching properties with a cadaver-dog team.

The series

Six chapters.
One continuing investigation.

Approximately 50 minutes per episode.
Currently in development.

01   Strangeland

02   Stick Season

03   From Away

04   Down East

05   Up Home

06   Finest Kind

Bring the series to listeners

We’re looking for a production partner.

Explore the reporting, recorded material, and plan for completing the season.

Get in touch

Have information or want to talk?

stabbyunicornmedia@gmail.com

Support for the investigation

The existing fundraiser supports the private investigation. It is separate from the podcast’s production funding.

View the investigation fundraiser →