The disappearance of Colin Arey
A missing person.
A town full of questions.
In 2017, Colin Arey, a young gay man from Bucksport, Maine, disappeared. Nearly a year and a half passed before anyone reported him missing.
Journalist Jacqui Fulton’s search leads to the deaths of Colin’s mother, Christy Appleby, and two other people, Robin Davis and her father, Kirk. Suspicious fires and financial schemes deepen the questions their families have about what happened.
Working with fact-checker Fendall Fulton and private investigator Jen Dorman, Jacqui follows the evidence through a community where people are afraid to speak. Their reporting has already helped reopen one closed case.


